Jerry And The Mermaid Jerry And The Mermaid
  • Home
  • Menu
  • About
  • Photos
  • Reviews
  • Location
  • Jerry And The Mermaid


    469 E Main St, Riverhead, NY 11901, United States


  • Jerry And The Mermaid


    +1 855-445-3072


Service options

+ Outdoor seating

+ No-contact delivery

+ Delivery

+ On-site services

+ Takeaway

+ Dine-in

Highlights

+ Fast service

+ Great beer selection

+ Great cocktails

+ Great coffee

+ Great dessert

+ Serves local specialty

+ Sport

Popular for

+ Lunch

+ Dinner

+ Solo dining

Accessibility

+ Wheelchair-accessible car park

+ Wheelchair-accessible entrance

+ Wheelchair-accessible seating

+ Wheelchair-accessible toilet

Offerings

+ Alcohol

+ Beer

+ Cocktails

+ Coffee

+ Comfort food

+ Happy-hour drinks

+ Happy-hour food

+ Late-night food

+ Private dining room

+ Quick bite

+ Small plates

+ Spirits

+ Vegan options

+ Vegetarian options

+ Wine

Dining options

+ Brunch

+ Lunch

+ Dinner

+ Catering

+ Dessert

+ Seating

+ Table service

Amenities

+ Bar on site

+ Toilet

+ Wi-Fi

+ Wi-Fi

Atmosphere

+ Casual

+ Cosy

+ Trendy

Crowd

+ Family friendly

+ Groups

+ Tourists

Planning

+ Dinner reservations recommended

+ Accepts reservations

Payments

+ Credit cards

+ Debit cards

+ NFC mobile payments

+ Credit cards

Children

+ Good for kids

+ High chairs

+ Kids' menu

Parking

+ Free of charge street parking

+ Free parking lot

+ On-site parking

+ Parking

Pets

+ Dogs allowed outside


Jerry And The Mermaid menu

Four High Carrot Cake

Layer upon layers of moist carrot cake, stuffed with raisins, walnuts and pineapple. Finished with smooth cream cheese icing and a drizzle of white chocolate ganache.

$

• Brownie Sundae

The star of these irresistible gluten-free brownies is the purely dark Honduran chocolate mixed into every batch. Topped with vanilla bean ice cream and homemade hot fudge.

$

Creme Brulee Cheesecake

The marriage of two great classics.. creme brulee layered and a-mingle with the lightest of cheesecakes to create something unimaginably luscious. Hand-fired and mirrored with burnt caramel.

$

Molten, Chocolate Cake

Five layers of dark, moist chocolate cake sandwiched with the silkiest smooth chocolate filling and finished with elegant dark chocolate ganache.

$

Creme Brulee D'jour

Jerry's homemade crème brulee! Ask your server for today's seasonal flavor.

$

Jerry's 'Homemade Ice Cream-Stuffed Crepe

Jerry's signature ice cream stuffed crepe with homemade hot fudge and whipped cream.

$

Baked Apple Tart

Warm baked apple tart with homemade caramel sauce. *This is baked to order and needs a few extra minutes to reach perfection - please pre-order!*

$

Chocolate 'Peanut /Butter Pie with REESE'S® Peanut Butter Cups

The popular candy bar in a pie. Dark chocolate and peanut butter mousse full of Reese's® Peanut Butter Cups.

$

Full Menu

Discover Jerry And The Mermaid

If you're looking for a charming spot to enjoy delicious seafood with a cozy, local vibe, Jerry And The Mermaid is a must-visit. Nestled in Riverhead, NY, at 469 E Main St, this beloved diner-style restaurant has earned a reputation for being a go-to destination for both locals and tourists alike. The moment you step inside, you'll feel right at home with its inviting atmosphere and friendly service.

One of the standout features of Jerry And The Mermaid is its menu. Whether you're a seafood aficionado or simply in the mood for something comforting, their diverse offerings cater to every taste. From fresh seafood dishes to hearty classics, the menu has something for everyone. The clam chowder is a local favorite, rich and creamy with a perfect balance of flavors. The fried calamari is another popular choice - perfectly crispy on the outside while tender inside, making it an irresistible appetizer.

But it’s not just seafood that shines here. If you’re craving something more traditional, the burgers and sandwiches are always a safe bet. The fish tacos, which are loaded with perfectly seasoned fish and fresh toppings, are a great option for those seeking a lighter meal. The menu is designed to offer variety, ensuring there's something to satisfy whatever craving you walk in with.

The location itself is an important part of the experience. Riverhead, NY, with its small-town charm, makes the setting even more delightful. The restaurant's vibe complements the surrounding area - casual, laid-back, and ideal for a relaxed meal with family or friends. Whether you’re grabbing a quick bite after a day of exploring the North Fork or enjoying a leisurely meal, Jerry And The Mermaid offers a space to unwind and enjoy great food.

But the real magic happens when you try the specials. The chefs at Jerry And The Mermaid often incorporate seasonal ingredients, ensuring that the dishes are as fresh and flavorful as possible. The specials change regularly, so there’s always something new to try on each visit. Many diners rave about the lobster roll, which features generous chunks of lobster meat piled high on a buttered roll. It's a crowd-pleaser that keeps people coming back for more.

In terms of service, Jerry And The Mermaid truly stands out. The staff is known for being attentive, friendly, and knowledgeable, always making sure guests feel comfortable. The relaxed atmosphere combined with the warm service makes it feel like you're dining at a friend’s place - where everyone knows your name, and the food is always spot-on.

For those planning to visit, it's important to know that the restaurant's location in Riverhead makes it a convenient stop for anyone touring the area. Riverhead itself is rich in history and has become a hub for wineries, beaches, and local attractions, making Jerry And The Mermaid an ideal place to stop and recharge during your adventures.

Customer reviews consistently highlight the quality of the food and the atmosphere. Many visitors comment on the consistent high quality of the dishes and the overall experience. With its casual vibe and commitment to serving delicious meals, it’s easy to see why Jerry And The Mermaid has become such a beloved spot in Riverhead.

Whether you're in town for a quick visit or you’re a local regular, Jerry And The Mermaid’s combination of quality food, friendly service, and inviting atmosphere makes it a must-try. The next time you find yourself in the area, make sure to stop by and see what all the buzz is about.


Jerry And The Mermaid Photos

Jerry And The Mermaid Photo -1
Jerry And The Mermaid Photo -2
Jerry And The Mermaid Photo -3
Jerry And The Mermaid Photo -4
Jerry And The Mermaid Photo -5
Jerry And The Mermaid Photo -6
Jerry And The Mermaid Photo -7
Jerry And The Mermaid Photo -8
Jerry And The Mermaid Photo -9
Jerry And The Mermaid Photo -10

Location & Contact

Get in touch with our support team


  • 469 E Main St, Riverhead, NY 11901, United States
  • +1 855-445-3072




Clock


Hours

Our open schedules

Day
Monday 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM
Tuesday 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM
Wednesday Closed
Thursday 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM
Friday 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Saturday 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Sunday 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM



Reviews

  • I’ve been coming to Jerry’s for over 15 years, and it’s still just as amazing as ever. The food remains top-notch, and it’s great to see Jerry’s son carrying on the tradition with the same high standards. Everything here is fresh, flavorful, and consistently well-prepared. The seafood is always incredibly fresh and tastes fantastic. The chicken wings are a must-try—they’re a classic appetizer and one of my all-time favorites. I also highly recommend the artichoke hearts, another standout appetizer. Between my family and me, we’ve tried just about everything on the menu, and there isn’t a single thing we’d complain about. The quality is always there. All the seafood dishes are fantastic! The steak is excellent, and the steak sandwich is one of the best around. Whether you’re stopping by for a quick lunch or a relaxed meal, Jerry’s is definitely worth a visit. And the bonus? A lovely little view of the water and boats that adds to the charm. You won’t be disappointed!

    mich1127
  • The lobster roll and sweet potato fries were absolutely delicious — fresh, well-seasoned, and nicely presented. The staff was so friendly and genuinely helpful — you can tell they really care about their guests. Plus, the bar has a lovely location with a view of the marina, which makes the atmosphere even better, especially in summer

    Bożena Wróblewska
  • We booked Jerry and The Mermaid for our rehearsal dinner and it was the best night ever! Jerry and his team were so accommodating, helpful and such a good time. Most importantly the food was incredible! All our guests were raving all wedding weekend (and still to this day asking to go back)! The service was exceptional. Everyone had a new drink right as they finished their last one & everyone was so kind! I was also a crazy bride who provided an outline for the decor thinking our family would set up when they arrived but Jerry’s team did it all and perfectly going above and beyond. It was so amazing working with Jerry and you should definitely book your next private event here! We can’t wait to visit again soon!

    Nicole Guarasci
  • My boyfriend and I stopped in after visiting the aquarium and were curious based on the great reviews and photos. I will say we were put off a little by the interior decor so we chose to sat outside. However, our waitress was super sweet and attentive. Also the food and drinks were divine! I don't think I've ever even a beyond burger faster! My boyfriend and I were also amazed by the waffle fries. Finally, the special canoli tartufo was so good I could not stop picking at it. It was worth every single penny!

    Danielle Adames
  • Spectacular! It was a wonderful experience with excellent seafood cuisine. Absolutely everything was perfect, from our super-fresh oyster starter to the main courses and the carrot cake—woah, perfect! The place has a lot of history with a beautiful view of the pier. The service from the staff was excellent, very friendly. Congratulations! !!!Highly recommended!!!!!

    A Hanna
  • I love seafood, but I'm from Nebraska, which is a double landlocked state. The fish here is the most delicious thing I've ever tasted. Our waitress was very pleasant and helped me choose which meal to order. She was also attentive to our needs. My friend had the chicken sandwich and also enjoyed it. If I ever make it back to this area, I will definitely eat here again.

    Brigette Staack
  • First, I had to look up how to write a review because I've never left one anywhere. The service and food was unmatched. I'm from the Midwest and had never had a lobster roll and wanted to try both. The chef prepared a small amount of the cold roll so I could also try it. Both were phenomenal. If you don't try the peanut butter pie you will without a doubt regret it. The server brought so much joy after an emotionally filled trip. They didn't know but we had just taken the ferry back from going to a memorial golf tournament from our best friend that passed away from our squadron. Go for the lobster, stay for the service, have pie, leave happy. Thanks for the delicious food and mutch needed laughter.

    Ashley V

Explore More Taste

  • 271 Reviews

    Curries & Spirits

    Curries & Spirits

    Indian Restaurant

    4/104 Fern St, Gerringong NSW 2534, Australia

  • 664 Reviews

    Tea Leaf 2

    Tea Leaf 2

    Chinese Restaurant

    4646 Pacific Ave SE, Lacey, WA 98503, United States

  • 1057 Reviews

    La Brioche Dalma Mall

    La Brioche Dalma Mall

    Cafe

    Delma mall - Abu Dhabi Industrial City - ICAD I - Abu Dhabi - United Arab Emirates

  • 293 Reviews

    Jaimy's Bistro En Steak - Zalen En Catering

    Jaimy's Bistro En Steak - Zalen En Catering

    Restaurant

    Burgemeester Rijpstrastraat 10, 7021 CR Zelhem, Netherlands

  • 1387 Reviews

    Settebello Pizzeria Napoletana

    Settebello Pizzeria Napoletana

    Pizza Restaurant

    140 S Green Valley Pkwy #102, Henderson, NV 89012, United States

  • 678 Reviews

    Tribute Coffee House

    Tribute Coffee House

    Cafe

    13960 Harbor Blvd, Garden Grove, CA 92843, United States

Jerry And The Mermaid

Discover Jerry And The Mermaid at 469 E Main St, Riverhead! Enjoy fresh seafood and a cozy vibe that keeps locals and visitors coming back for more. Dive into deliciousness today!

The information here is community-driven and not from an official source. If you are the site owner, we welcome you to contact us.